The Real, Fake Red Book of Westmarch


I have an article up at The Toast, called “How I Defeated the Tolkien Estate”, a satirical short story about me being a Hobbit Studies scholar who discovered an unauthorized copy of the “Red Book of Westmarch,” published my own translation of The Lord of the Rings and, was subsequently sued by the Tolkien Estate. It’s accompanied by an amazing set of illustrations by the artist Jason Longo, including Balrog judges, Gollum as a sleazy lawyer, Elrond serving papers, a dessicated dwarf dressed as an University of Chicago undergrad, and yours truly as Frodo.

The inspiration for the piece is Tolkien’s own claim, in the Lord of the Rings appendices, that he is merely translating Bilbo and Frodo’s own writings as collected in “The Red Book of Westmarch” (you can see Ian Holm and Elijah Wood writing in the Red Book in Peter Jackson’s LOTR and Hobbit trilogies). Tolkien always posited Middle-earth as our own earth in a more ancient and mythical time, and even his earliest Middle-earth writings (dating to 1917) that conceit is there: this isn’t fantasy, it’s history.

A number of authors have claimed their texts are “translations” from some other book or manuscript (see also: The Princess Bride), but Tolkien, being a linguist, took it a step further. Think “Samwise Gamgee” is a strange, fantasy-sounding name? It is. But, according to Tolkien, it’s also a translation, rendered into a vaguely English-sounding name from the original Westron. Samwise’s true name? Banazîr Galbasi.

It’s this sort of multi-layered nerdery that’s made Tolkien’s books so popular over the decades. For the piece, I decided to take Tolkien at his word, and take the conceit to its absurd end. If Tolkien is merely a translator of an ancient text, what would happen if someone else found “The Red Book” and translated it? And what if that someone liked making jokes about hobbit sex and orc dicks? What would the famously litigious Tolkien Estate do?

The piece has gotten a lot of great feedback and been shared all over the place: currently over 2,000 times on Facebook, nearly 4,000 times on Pinterest, even 230 times on Google + (I’m especially touched that 230 people opened their dusty Google + accounts after years of neglect just to share my piece). It even got its own write up at, one of the biggest scifi/fantasy sites around, who called it “incredibly funny” and “hilarious.”

Some people have actually responded too well, and have searched for/asked me where to find The Lord of the Rings: A New English Translation (traffic on this blog has spiked thanks to people searching for my name and that title – sorry y’all!). I admit, I’ve been a little amused by the number of people who’ve thought the story true.

But mostly, I’m just overwhelmed by the positive response. As a writer, it’s been incredibly gratifying to have so many people reading and liking something I’ve written! Honestly, it’s a dream come true.

Getting a piece published at The Toast is also basically a dream realized. It’s my favorite website. I’ve been wanting to pitch them something for a while now, but never had any ideas I thought worthy of them.

Then a few months ago, the great Mallory Ortberg of The Toast wrote a typically hilarious and smart piece called Signs the Book You’re Reading Is Going to Be a Good One, such as “a good map, with plausible coastlines.” In the (ever excellent at The Toast) comments, commenter ecurve added, “The author claims, or loudly hints, that the story is actually true and was only *translated* by him/her.” To which I made a silly comment about beating the Tolkien Estate in court when I published my own translation of the Red Book. Mallory then replied, “YOU MUST WRITE ABOUT THIS FOR US” and after a few hours of panicked, imposter syndrome hyperventilating, I got to work.

And the rest is fake history.



Add yours →

  1. What a brilliant article. That’s all.

  2. I really enjoyed reading it after seeing a friend post it on Facebook! You can count my googling of your name towards the spike in traffic. Carry on, good sir!

  3. Thank you so much! I’m glad you enjoyed the story!

  4. btw this may interest you — kept running through my head as I was reading your piece — it is far from identical/not at all the same, still you may find it amusing.

  5. It was so witty.
    Incidentally, were you sued by the Tolkien estate for this article?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Sarah Hollowell

fat writer girl and her fat words

massive hassle

adventures in gender, pop culture and snark

S. Qiouyi Lu

for just one moment, I miss home.

Naturally Lilly's

An Etsy Crafter's and Booklover's Blog

Elizabeth Rose Stanton - Penspaper Studio

Just another weblog

This Kid Reviews Books

A Place for Kids and Grown-Ups to Discover Books


… a collection of thoughts on being American, Asian and adopted

Fabulous. Friendly. Homemade.

The Rabid Rainbow Ferret Society

The Adventures of Six Mad Writers

True Confessions of a Gen-X Trekkie

Trekkie "of a certain age" - "returning adult learner" - adventures in college television - doing my best to not move into my mom's basement

Underneath the Juniper Tree

Not your little sister's bedtime stories...

Emily L. Hauser - In My Head

Writer, social activist, a lot of Israel/Palestine, and general mental rambling

Lara Ehrlich Editorial

Everyone needs an editor. I'll be yours.

%d bloggers like this: